Charles opened by stating the industry is still in the experimental stage, with tokenized assets at just one basis point of the total addressable market. Zach added that a 1,000x growth in tokenized asset volume over five years is a likely figure, yet the crypto-native audience is reluctant to invest in the smart contract platforms that will host those assets. Thomas described a three-phase lifecycle: issuance, access, and utility. He believes the industry is currently stuck between access and utility, with many assets onchain but few real use cases beyond experimental memes combined with RWAs.
Charles explained that two years ago, storage protocols showed returns but no risk data. S&P’s new vault risk assessment methodology addresses this by analyzing blockchain risk, issuer risk, liquidity mismatch, and underlying asset quality. The real use case for tokenized money market funds is collateral, enabling lending against securities. Charles sees vaults as the next generation of pooled investment vehicles, following mutual funds and ETFs, but risk transparency is the missing link for institutional adoption.
Zach argued that in the very long term, tokenization will make ETFs obsolete, but that future is distant. He noted that Bitcoin ETFs now hold about 6% of the Bitcoin supply, and demand for crypto ETFs will continue growing. Thomas added that tokenized stocks need to offer a tenfold better experience than traditional brokerages, packaged into one or two clicks, before they can compete. He also said institutional trust, such as S&P’s risk assessments, gives confidence that an asset has been approved by a blue-chip institution, which is critical for packaging tokenized assets for non-crypto-native users.