Skip to content

$LDO $BCH

2 Jul 202411 min

Lido ($LDO) has been one of the strongest coins since the $ETH spot ETF news came out. It is also one of the few tokens that have managed to outperform over the past 3 weeks while $BTC, $ETH, and other altcoins continued to bleed.

Source: TradingView – Besides outperforming majors, $LDO also stood out acting as beta to $ETH, overshadowing other coins in that bucket such as $ARB or $MATIC

However, things went south on Friday when the SEC alleged that Lido’s and Rocket Pool’s staking programs are securities.

Source: db news – SEC vs Consensys Complaint

First and foremost, chasing beta has proven to be a losing strategy, as exemplified by the outperformance of $BTC and $ETH versus new tokens entering the market at large FDVs.

Source: TradingView – Majors have outperformed alts and newly launched tokens since the start of the year; buying the “new shiny” coin is not a winning strategy.

By suggesting a long in $LDO we are not looking for beta or leveraged exposure to an $ETH spot ETF that has been telegraphed and literally every participant in this market is already aware of. Instead, we like this trade, paired with a short position in $BCH, because of the flexibility and optionality that comes with it, betting on the mean reversion of an outperformer that has been halted by ambiguous and vague news.

Source: TradingView – $LDO versus $BCH has been sideways since March, only disturbed by two sudden wicks.

Even though the chart above paints a picture that makes it seem as if there was solid support at the 0.004 level, we don’t necessarily think this a pair trade that should be symmetrically executed. Rather than having 50/50 exposure to each of the legs with equal size, we reiterate that flexibility and optionality are the key characteristics we are looking for.

For that reason, we think it is reasonable to wait for the $LDO waters to calm down and keep track of how it reacts to unfolding news on the $ETH spot ETF front. Similarly, $BCH will be one to add to the short book at opportunistic times, trimming and adding size accordingly. As it pertains to $BTC and $BCH, the Mt Gox repayments can start at any point from the beginning of July. This news might explain the last 18 days of selling with a steeper selloff on that day, but it is also worth keeping in mind that some people have been waiting more than 10 years for this. The reported amount for $BCH, however, is not significant ($51M or 143k $BCH), but it is a token that is highly correlated to $BTC, for which Mt Gox holds 142k $BTC or $8.7B.

Source: TradingView – $BTC is revisiting the lower end of a sideways range, making it appealing to hedge any upside with a short position in case of a break to the downside.

The last thing we want to do in the current environment, characterized by decreasing trading volumes and absence of marginal buyers, is catch a falling knife.

Source: Kaiko – Aggregate trading volume on spot $BTC has been on a downtrend since the March highs.

In addition to that, Bitcoin’s correlation to the S&P and the Nasdaq has been on a decline, with US equities making new highs as $BTC approaches the lower end of the range at $60k.

Source: The Block Data – $BTC’s 30-day correlation has gone negative despite being at 0.8 at the start of June.

For the short leg of this pair trade, we are looking at $BCH as a way to hedge against the weakness of the overall market. This is an asset that is highly correlated to $BTC and for which we don’t see many tailwinds that might reprice it to the upside. With that upside risk limited due to lack of catalysts other than positive $BTC action we are comfortable using $BCH as a short in the portfolio.

Source: CoinMetrics – The correlation between $BCH and $BTC dropped to a low of 0.2 in April and rapidly increased again, now holding above 0.8 and suggesting a strong correlation.

Both of the coins involved in this pair have been on the market for years, and most of the supply is already in circulation. We are going in the opposite direction of the current low-float and high-fdv meta. The idea is to simultaneously avoid exposure to large supply unlocks with no subsequent demand (as has been the case with most recent launches), as well as to avert the short squeezes and prolonged periods of negative funding that characterize these low-float tokens.

Source: Velo – Low-float and high-fdv tokens like $ENA, $ZRO, $STRK, or $MANTA show prolonged trends of negative funding, which eat into the upside potential of opening a position against them.

This takes us to the next point, which is the fact that we are concerned about so many tokens entering the market at once, especially when they are expected to start trading at multibillion-dollar valuations. The market cap of crypto continues to grow as more and more projects launch their tokens, further resulting in a decrease in token prices as the supply gradually unlocks to maintain an equilibrium. However, this has created a market that is saturated with new tokens and no willing buyers to step in with fresh capital.

Source: Binance Research – In 2024 we are seeing the lowest market cap/FDV ratio of the past three years for newly launched tokens.

While the absence of marginal buyers limits the upside on the spot markets, the dislocation in the perps markets is a threat to anyone taking the opposite side of the consensus view. In other words, even if the consensus view is that low-float and high-fdv tokens will underperform majors (as has been the case since the start of the year, or even since the $TIA and $JTO airdrops), the market can experience short spurs of irrationality. For that reason, we don’t want to take risks of being exposed to short squeezes in addition to paying large amounts of negative funding shorting these tokens.

Source: Velo – Liquidations tend to be either more aggressive or more frequent on the short side, resulting in short squeezes.

A long position in $LDO exposes us to a project that has most tokens in circulation, while a short in $BCH gives us a high correlation to $BTC. This doesn’t mean that we are ruling out the possibility of a short squeeze in $BCH. Instead, our intention is to suggest that $BCH is a token with less mindshare and attention going into it, as it is considered by many a “dinosaur” coin and we believe that there won’t be much demand for it in the spot markets.

Source: TradingView – Even if $BCH is in a downtrend versus $BTC, there is a precedent in March that might occur again and for which we must exercise caution.

On the one hand, Lido is one of the few protocols in all of DeFi that can manage to generate sustained levels of revenue from its operations. On the other hand, picking an asset like $BCH for the short leg of the trade allows us to derisk the dependence on a dedicated team of contributors as well as any potential marketing tactics or roadmap promises.

Source: Token Terminal – Lido has generated over $500M in cumulative fees, more than other DeFi blue chips like MakerDAO and Aave combined.

While $LDO is expected to receive more mindshare and may ride the tailwinds pushing $ETH higher, $BCH is a digital commodity where nothing is really going on and for which we don’t anticipate increasing amounts of net new demand.

Source: kaito.ai – Even after the most recent sentiment drop, $LDO’s mindshare has reached yearly highs after the SEC mention.

Lido’s business model is extremely simple and easy to understand. It also stands out as the clear winner and holder of a monopoly in a winner-takes-all market such as liquid staking. Contrast this with the abstract and ambiguous dynamics that characterize new verticals like restaking, where there are multiple players competing for market share.

Source: Dune Ethereum Staking Dashboard by Hildobby – Lido holds more than 85% of the LST market share, while the largest player among LRT holds 58%, showing more dispersion between players.

We already know that liquid staking is here to stay, and that Lido is by far the most dominant player. Restaking only makes this thesis stronger, as we can own an asset where most tokens are in circulation already, unlike the large supply shocks that will define most governance tokens of LRT protocols.

LSTs compete for moneyness (yield-bearing version of $ETH with staking rewards coming from the underlying chain), not just an absolute value for yield (otherwise Lido wouldn’t be the clear winner), while LRTs are heterogeneous and prone to engage in risk-taking behavior to eat into their competitors’ slice of the pie.

Source: Dune Ethereum Staking Dashboard by Hildobby – There is a clear winner among LSTs, whereas participants are more likely to have a hard time predicting who the winner will be among so many LRTs.

Additionally, Lido’s upside is not necessarily capped. Even if it continues to be the target for vampire attacks and the community continues pushing for rate-limiting and not having it exceed the 33% threshold of all staked $ETH, this ratio can grow even further. Ethereum’s staking ratio is one of the lowest among all Proof of Stake (PoS) chains, currently at 27% while most others stand above 60%.

Source: Stakingrewards.com – Lido’s revenue increases in tandem with its Assets Under Management (AUM), signaling that there is more room for growth as Ethereum’s staking ratio continues to increase.

Notably, the elephant in the room is again the lack of regulatory clarity, as $LDO is a simple governance token with no value accrual. This is not necessarily a bad thing, as any proposal to turn on a fee switch can be a very powerful catalyst.

Source: Tradingview – The market already showed its hand when the $UNI price jumped from $7 to $10 in less than an hour after a governance proposal hit the forum suggesting to turn on the fee switch and reward $UNI holders.

As a matter of fact, Uniswap Labs also received a Wells notice in April – essentially a heads-up from the SEC notifying that the regulators believe they have broken the law. We expect this to be a similar blip on the radar for Lido.

Many tokens have been considered securities in the eyes of the SEC and nothing has prevented them from continuing to go up. There is usually a small bump on the road with a large red daily candle, but over a long enough period of time this event vanishes from the memory of the current market participants. Gensler’s time at the SEC is also ticking, with very little time to cause further panic before the upcoming elections.

$SOL was classified as a security alongside other tokens like $NEAR, $MATIC, or $ADA, and is up more than 700% since then. That hasn’t prevented VanEck from filing a spot $SOL ETF, even if there is no futures ETF yet (which makes it unattractive for executing carry trades and attracting large sums of inflows, but that’s a topic for another time).

Source: TradingView – Current market participants don’t put a lot of weight into the SEC’s labels, having no problems to buy $SOL when they expect to see relative outperformance to the overall market.

Another example of this is $XRP, which has managed to be on the top 10 of tokens by market cap despite an ongoing fight versus the SEC that has spanned for multiple years.

Being labeled a security is not an overhang in the grand scheme of things, or at least that’s not how the current players in this market see it. There is an implicit assumption among current participants that most tokens are indeed securities, possibly excluding some L1s like $LTC, $BCH, and even $DOGE. This is known information, and the SEC has shown their hand on multiple occasions already.

The selective enforcement of certain tokens is not limited to the assets being mentioned in these public statements. Instead, it signals that there is a looming regulatory shadow that creates a lot of uncertainty, but this is not limited to tokens like $SOL, $XRP, $MATIC, or $LDO. If those tokens are securities, does that imply that the remaining thousands of tokens in Coingecko are not securities? Certainly not.

A daily drawdown of ~20% serves as a reminder that it always looks ugliest when there is a red candle in front of the screen. Meanwhile, $LDO was one to watch over the past three weeks given its outperformance and strength while $BTC approached $60k.

Source: TradingView – In the period of time between June 11 and Jun 27 $LDO was up 50% versus $BTC.

Source: TradingView – Zooming out paints a different picture, with $LDO being 60% down versus $BTC since January 10.

That being said, none of the above implies that $LDO can’t continue to go lower and eventually consolidate below $2, even with more room to go down if the $ETH ETF inflows turn out to be underwhelming or the overall market simply tanks.

Note that with this trade we are looking for flexibility and optionality, reserving the right to get out of the position or double down as new information comes out. We reiterate that chasing beta tends to be a losing strategy. At the same time, coins like $BCH won’t ever file for bankruptcy, and they won’t easily erase millions of their market cap in short timeframes.

The key is to not marry this position, as there will be plenty of times to get out of it at a profit as well as to double down. This is not a pair trade for which we are willing to stomach a large drawdown, and it is crucial to be vigilant every time both legs of the pair trade are active on the book.

At the end of the day, the optimal play is to have the ability to change your positioning at any time based on new information flows. You could be long $LDO one day and short $ETH the next day – it is all about adjusting the exposure to the market. This pair trade is all about the optionality that comes with exposure to $ETH and the protection versus scenarios where the market tanks and $BTC drops below $60k.

Disclosures

Alea Research has never had a commercial relationship with any of the names mentioned above and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.

Members of the Alea Research team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.

This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Alea Research is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.

Alea Research · 2 Jul 2024 · 11 min

Back to top